FA Vase
First qualifying round
AFC St Austell 2 Bodmin Town 1
In the end St Austell were grateful for the excellent start they made to a thrilling tie as Bodmin threw everything at them in a rampant second half show at Poltair.
The Lillywhites looked to be on their way to a big victory after Martyn Duff, with an excellent strike in the sixth minute, and Olly Brokenshire (12 minutes) put them 2-0 ahead.
But Bodmin, being managed on a temporary basis by Shaun Vincent following Dane Bunney’s shock resignation, got themselves back into the tie with a Ben Waters goal in the 32nd minute and were then the better side as they searched for an equaliser.
They could argue with some justification that they should have been awarded two second half penalties when Waters and Charlie Hardcastle were both brought down but the referee was not in a giving mood.
Vincent described the performance as one of the best Bodmin have produced in recent times and although disappointed by their exit from the Vase, he couldn’t fault the effort after their poor start and said it augured well for the rest of the season.
That poor start included some rank bad defending as they were given and failed to carry out several chances to clear their penalty area from a sixth minute corner.
The ball then fell to Duff on the far side of the area; he still had a lot to do but once he transferred the ball onto his left foot he seized the opportunity to drill the ball into the far corner.
The home lead was doubled six minutes later when a precision corner from skipper Neil Slateford was flicked on at the near post to Brokenshire, who volleyed into the net from 10 yards.
St Austell almost made it 3-0 on the half-hour when the evergreen Liam Eddy strode away from a covering defender but pulled his shot just wide with Bodmin keeper Jordan Stidson rooted to his line.
It was a let off for the visitors, who responded by reducing the arrears two minutes later as they opened up the St Austell defence through the middle and Waters finished superbly with keeper Harry Ashton standing in his way.
Bodmin came close to equalising a minute before half-time when Hardcastle, out wide on the left, produced a superb cross which found Ross Hamilton, who volleyed inches over the bar.
The visitors should have had a 52nd minute penalty when Waters went down under the challenge of two players but the referee thought otherwise and to compound what looked a poor decision, sent Sam Clifton to the sin bin for arguing.
By the letter of the law he was right – referees do not deserve verbal abuse; there just seems no room whatsoever for the emotion of the moment in football any more, and that’s a great shame.
St Austell, on the back foot for long spells, suddenly broke clear after 76 minutes and only a top drawer save from Stidson kept out a close range Eddy shot.
Bodmin’s second strong penalty shout came five minutes later when Hardcastle was clearly clipped by a defender but the referee and the nearest linesman said no.
The visitors, with substitute Kevin Kendall running the show from midfield for the last 15 minutes, which included 10 minutes of time added on, pressed hard for an equaliser which would have led to a penalty shootout. But they couldn’t find a way through.
St Austell: H Ashton, J Shaw, T Whipp, M Watts (B Thomas 21), O Brokenshire, A Carter, N Slateford, M Duff (N Teagle 71), L Eddy, T Guest (G Marris 46), J Miller.
Subs not used: M Searle, C Wharton, O Rosevear, C Hill (gk).
Goals: M Duff (6), O Brokenshire (12).
Yellow cards: T Guest (25), T Whipp (87), B Thomas (90+10).
Bodmin: J Stidson, S Hill, R Hamilton, L Pacey, A Wall, C Holder, L Taylor (K Foster), S Clifton, B Waters, J Hamson (K Kendall 85), C Hardcastle.
Sub not used: J Robertson.
Goal: B Waters (32).
Yellow cards: L Taylor (40), B Waters (77), A Wall (90).
Sin Bin: S Clifton (54).
Referee: A Bassett.
Attendance: 150.